Butterfly Conservation - saving butterflies, moths and their habitats
Butterfly Conservation
saving butterflies, moths and our environment
   Upper Thames Branch
UTB Branch Menu
 » Homepage
 » Introduction & News
 » Conservation
 » Butterfly Sightings
 » Moth Sightings
 » Churchyards
 » UTB Butterflies
 » UTB Moths
 » Champions
 » Events
 » Sites
 » Your Records
 » Committee/Contacts
 » Sitemap & Updates
Links to the national Butterfly Conservation website
 » BC Membership
 » National Website
 » Other Links

Home > Conservation > The Chalkhill Blue at Holtspur Bottom Reserve

The Chalkhill Blue at Holtspur Bottom Reserve

Report by Nick Bowles
November 2011


Elderly residents of the Holtspur area, between High Wycombe and Beaconsfield, have told us that they recall seeing Chalkhill Blue butterflies in the Holtspur Valley. Unfortunately, there were no written records of it ever having been seen there and modern surveys had failed to detect it. However, this is a highly mobile species. The males (at least) are recorded well away from any known colony every year.

So when we pushed back topsoil to make a feature called a 'scrape' (in winter 2003/4) in addition to planting Kidney Vetch (to improve conditions for the scarce Small Blue which was sporadically present on the reserve) we planted Horseshoe Vetch, the foodplant of the larvae of Chalkhill Blue. We hoped that some vagrants of both species would wander back.


Chalkhill Blue pair
Photo © Nick Bowles

Horseshoe Vetch
Photo © Nick Bowles



Horseshoe Vetch is the only known food plant of the Chalkhill Blue. Which is a shame in more ways than one; it is relatively hard to grow, expensive to buy and disappears from both overgrazed meadows and meadows that suffer grazing neglect. Even so, we committed to create sufficient habitat to support a viable colony of the butterfly, over a number of years.

The first scrape was an evident success in terms of the amount of vetch that flowered within 4 years of us planting tiny plants into the bare sub-soil that we had exposed. Our studies of the Chalkhill Blue, however, suggested that a single large area of vetch would be less successful than several adjacent areas of vetch. So a second scrape, backed on the 'up-hill' side by a low bank of spoil, was put in during the winter 08/09. This second feature was positioned where the chalk was deeper beneath the top soil, so we had to plant into a thin layer of topsoil rather than sub-soil. We had some concerns that the Horseshoe Vetch would thrive here as it had in the first position. Luckily, it seems to be coping well, but we will need to keep the area relatively clear of other rampant vegetation for some years before it can 'look after itself'.

Our first scrape exposed bedrock chalk,
which suits vetches better than grasses.
The yellow flowers of the vetches are obvious.
Photo © Nick Bowles

There have been other beneficiaries of the second
scrape, like this scarce arable weed, Round-leaved Fluellen.
Photo © Nick Bowles



Spring 2011 was really helpful to butterflies and moths. One result was early flight periods in June and July, with dispersal of many species away from larger colonies. This benefitted several species and in August we received news that a male Chalkhill had been seen at Holtspur Bottom. Small groups of would-be observers were soon to confirm that this wasn't a single vagrant male but several butterflies. Both sexes were seen and eventually a female was observed egg-laying.

The return of the Chalkhill Blue is very welcome. However, the true measure of the reserve's successful management will be if we can maintain a colony here into the future. There will need to be work to see that the amounts of Horseshoe Vetch continue to increase, probably through planting small amounts every year, but hopefully through natural self-seeding. Probably though the creation and 'plug' planting of further scrapes, as the existing scrapes slowly succumb to denser vegetation, which outcompete the butterflies' foodplants.

We shall also survey the local area to see if other colonies are hiding, undiscovered nearby.

Part of the Holtspur volunteer team erect
temporary fencing to protect essential
vetch foodplants from sheep.
Photo © Nick Bowles



The first Chalkhill Blue egg
to be seen at Holtspur for
many years.
Photo © Wendy Wilson

A male Chalkhill Blue at Holtspur Bottom
in August 2011. Hopefully, the first
of many.
Photo © Wendy Wilson


  (Click photos for larger images.)

top of page

Copyright Butterfly Conservation © 2007-2011 Upper Thames Branch
Privacy and Copyright Statement
Butterfly Conservation: Company limited by guarantee, registered in England (2206468)
Registered Office: Manor Yard, East Lulworth, Wareham, Dorset, BH20 5QP
Charity registered in England & Wales (254937) and in Scotland (SCO39268)